""We have discussions like this all the time in my philosophy classes. Theists and atheists alike should be willing to engage in debate all the time, otherwise they risk never having the flaws in their reasoning pointed out.
Whoever wrote this though created a total straw-man. And they labelled the straw-man as "professor" in order to further try to legitimize it.""
You should check out my reincarnation thread; doesn't look like there were many atheists present to legitimize the discussion. Tell me what you think as this quote has piqued my interest.